Grill Perfect Baked Potatoes in Foil: A Mouthwatering Story with Stats and Tips [Ultimate Guide]

What is Baked Potatoes on the Grill in Foil?

Baked potatoes on the grill in foil is a classic way of making delicious and tender potatoes. This cooking method entails wrapping the potato with aluminum foil and grilling it until it’s soft and cooked all the way through inside. It is a simple technique that requires minimum effort, yet produces tasty results your family will love!

Step-by-Step: How to Grill the Perfect Baked Potato in Foil

Grilling is one of the most beloved summer activities, and nothing quite beats the sizzling sound of a baked potato being grilled to perfection in foil. There’s just something about biting into a deliciously fluffy and crispy baked potato that can’t be beat. If you’ve ever tried your hand at this humble side dish before and ended up with less-than-stellar results, don’t worry – we’re here to help. In this step-by-step guide, we’ll show you how to grill the perfect baked potatoes in foil every time.

Step 1: Choose the right spuds

The first step in creating your ultimate grilled potatoes begins with choosing the right kind of spud. When it comes to excellent-quality baking potatoes for grilling, there’s no better choice than Russet potatoes – commonly known as Idaho or Baker Potatoes. They have thick skins that crisp up perfectly on the grill while keeping their shape intact while cooking through.

Step 2: Prep your taters

Give each potato a good scrub under cold running water using vegetable brush bristles (to remove all dirt). Pat them dry with paper towel or clean kitchen towels until completely dry.

Next, take toothpicks – slide two perpendicularly through each potato horizontally; these will provide holes needed for heat circulation helps prevent uneven cooked spots inside.

Rub down washed pat-dried-potato-skins evenly with melted unsalted butter from edges towards center add salt & pepper seasoning according to preference on both sides evenly by rubbing over again .

Once seasoned wrap it tightly in aluminum foil twice so that maximum heat stays within also adding onions/spring onions/garlic etc., if desired- This will give an extra dimension of flavor!

Step 3: Heat ’em up

Preheat your grill anywhere between medium-high heat temperature range (400°F-450°F) ; The hotter grate surface areas are usually directly above flames/convection sources like burners, so it is recommended to use indirect grilling method i.e., place potatoes on grill over flameless areas only (Again when using high heat temperature ranges, carefully observe and adjust the temperature accordingly.)

Step 4: Let them Grill!

Grill your spuds for about 45-60 minutes. It may sound like a long time but remember you want to slow cook these delicious baked potatoes in foil.

The larger/ thicker taters might take slightly longer than smaller ones. Open up and poke fork or toothpick (same we inserted– see “step2”) inside each one individually checking till it feels soft enough i.e., easy piercing through without resistance .

Once done remove from heat source letting sit for around five minutes before unwrapping them fully.

Slice open maintaining cross-cut style gently pull on both ends at once creating an opening – add any desired toppings of choice such as sour cream or green onions!

Voila! You have crafted yourself a perfect grilled baked potato in no time flat! The crispy skin with fluffy interior that melts tantalizingly over tongue is always appreciated by family & friends straight out of the sizzling hot gridiron; they will adore your culinary skills chef’s kiss. Enjoy !

Frequently Asked Questions about Baked Potatoes on the Grill in Foil

Baked potatoes on the grill are a classic and easy addition to any outdoor cookout. However, figuring out the best way to prepare them can sometimes be confusing. One popular method is wrapping them in foil before grilling, but this brings up several common questions that we will address below.

Q: Should I wrap my potatoes in aluminum foil before putting them on the grill?

A: Wrapping your baked potatoes in aluminum foil can help with even cooking and prevent ash or other debris from sticking to the skins. It also locks in moisture, creating an incredibly tender potato. Just make sure you leave enough space for steam to escape through small air holes or slits cut into the top of the packet.

Q: How long should I cook my wrapped baked potatoes on the grill?

A: Cooking time depends on many factors such as temperature of your grill and thickness of your potato slice so it could range from 30 minutes to 1 hour while flipping every now and then. The best thing is always check if it’s ready by lightly squeezing it — if it gives easily, then they’re done.

Q: Can I put toppings like butter or sour cream inside of my foil-wrapped baked potato?

A: Yes! Butter melts perfectly within its cocoon-like structure, infusing both flavor and moisture back into your spuds; once they’re cooked take off their skin with gloves without disturbing what’s inside fully open one side at least pour melted unsalted butter onto a spoonful scoop(s) add sea salt freshly ground black pepper goat cheese (optional). Sour cream works well too, just hold off until after they’ve been unwrapped.

Q: Can I add additional ingredients or spices when grilling wrapped baked potatoes?

A: Absolutely! Experimenting with flavors is half the fun of trying new recipes Simply brush sliced garlic cloves over both sides along bacon bits seasonings during preparation prior placing packets around indirect heat zone depending upon your taste stir in chopped fresh herbs, like rosemary or parsley after cooked.

Q: Are there any safety concerns when grilling wrapped potatoes?

A: While foil itself is generally safe to use for cooking, make sure you wrap them securely with no torn parts. Torn foil can create sharp edges which could puncture the potato wall and wrapping too tightly can cause potential bursting so be careful while un-wrapping from grill using gloves.

In conclusion, grilled baked potatoes are a fabulous addition to your outdoor cookout menu. Wrapping potatoes in aluminum foil not only ensures even cooking but also helps lock in moisture making an incredibly tender bite every time! By following these frequently asked questions about baking potatoes on the grill we hope have helped clear up any confusion regarding this classic dish while paving way for new culinary adventures based upon your personal taste preferences. Let’s get creating some delicious flavors now!

Top 5 Interesting Facts About Grilling Baked Potatoes in Foil

Summer is the perfect time to fire up the grill and enjoy some delicious outdoor cooking. While hamburgers, hot dogs, and steaks are a must-have at any barbecue, have you ever thought about grilling baked potatoes? Yes, you read that right – baked potatoes on the grill! Not only do they make a great side dish for your favorite grilled meats, but they’re also super easy to prepare.

Here are the top 5 interesting facts about grilling baked potatoes in foil:

1. The Foil Makes a Difference

Wrapping your spuds in aluminum foil before placing them on the grill helps protect them from burning while simultaneously ensuring even cooking through convection heating. Plus, it’s way easier than scrubbing out charred potato bits from metal grates!

2. They can be Cleaned Using Toothbrushes

We all know how difficult it could be to clean potatoes off burnt-on grease or sauces after grilling them directly on open flames. However with baking wraps around these spuds; cleaning becomes easy as pie! Simply use an old toothbrush and gently scrub away any remaining dirt or ash left behind by those tasty smoky flavors.

3. Timing is Key

You don’t want undercooked or overcooked potatoes ruining your meal specially when hosting guests outside of family members indoors during colder months meals .Timing plays important role whether you’re baking sweet corn or four large Idaho russet.
Keep an eye out while keeping lid closed so that temperature inside won’t drop down drastically which may put flameout risk without damaging contents .

4.The RIGHT COALS Matter

Having perfectly heat regulated coals means if we need low &slow cook will take longer where higher heat required fast cooking times available surly come handy ! Alt-hough charcoal briquettes get most BBQ love due consistency ,lump charcoal fanned into shape retaining natural flavor organic origin woods such as cherrywood hickory feels better .

5. The Versatility of Toppings and Filling

Perhaps the best part about grilling baked potatoes in foil is that they are so versatile. You can fill them with a variety of toppings to match your personal taste preference, from butter and salt to cheese, bacon bits and sour cream! Or maybe try something unconventional like leftover chili or pulled pork.

In summary; baking wraps on grill offers wonderful option for nutrients rich spuds whether you’re craving the traditional morning breakfast bite or hosting outdoor dinner guests . Plus ,the creative topping options go way beyond plain old butter&salt standard fare adding extra flavors makes each potato unique choice catering palates all aged foodies out there . So next time anytime during summer season or winter take advantage by reaching outside for this recipe & make some scrumptious grilled potatoes!

The Best Seasonings and Toppings for Your Grilled Foil-Wrapped Potatoes

Grilled Foil-Wrapped Potatoes are a classic summer BBQ side dish, and for good reason. Easy to prepare and absolutely delicious, this tasty treat is one of the best recipes for outdoor grilling enthusiasts.

One of the great things about Grilled Foil-Wrapped Potatoes is their versatility when it comes to seasoning combinations. Whether you prefer simple flavors or more complex ones, there’s sure to be an option that suits your taste buds perfectly.

So without further ado, let’s dive in and discover some of the best seasonings and toppings for these heavenly spuds!

1. Garlic Butter

Garlic butter makes everything better, right? And it’s no exception with grilled foil-wrapped potatoes! Just mix together garlic, butter (or margarine), chopped parsley, salt, and pepper. Spread over the potatoes before wrapping them up in foil – and let your guests’ mouths water as soon as they catch a whiff of that aromatic herby goodness.

2. Parmesan Cheese

For cheese lovers who can’t get enough parmesan on anything crunchy or crispy baked – wait till you try it with our Grilled Potato recipe! Sprinkle shredded parmesan cheese generously over each layer of sliced potatoes then wrap them into separate portions per serving size before tossing onto your grill until done perfection.

3. Lemon-Herb

If you’re looking for something light yet flavourful which will tingle those taste-buds try using fresh herbs such as rosemary thyme or tarragon mixed together with freshly squeezed lemon juice in olive oil – just pour mixture all over potato slices packing into individual parcels so they remain crisp whilst cooking.

4. Taco Seasoning

Taco seasoning isn’t just meant for beef tacos; why not try creating a delectable Mexican-style twist on Grilled Foil Wrapped Potatoes by adding taco seasoning instead? Mix together cumin powder chili powder smoked paprika onion powder garlic powder and salt for the perfect blend of spices. Coating sliced potatoes in this mixture before wrapping them in foil and popping onto a hot grill ensures that you will be left with an excitingly tasty side dish.

5. Brown Sugar

For those who lean towards sweeter, more decadent flavor options, try mixing some brown sugar into your BBQ sauce or marinade when preparing your grilled foil wrapped potatoes. The natural sweetness in the brown sugar combined with tangy salty flavors melds together so intensely ensuring joyously flavored well-rounded cubed spuds cut perfectly for any summertime cookout agenda!


All these seasoning ideas are just the beginning! You can always experiment by adding different herbs, spices, cheeses to see what works best for you – don’t shy away from getting creative and exploring all tastes suitable to complementing all cooked foods outdoors.

With Grilled Foil-Wrapped Potatoes being such an easy way to elevate any backyard BBQ experience; it’s no wonder they’re a popular go-to side dish.

Choose the combination that sounds most appealing to you right now – explore tantalizing Tacos flavours with chili powder and cumin or perhaps enhance lemon citrus zest blended within thyme herb plus honey butter flavour whilst considering generous portions of shredded parmesan cheese otherside baked on perfection & come joining us at our next summer event!’

How to Store and Reheat Your Leftover Grilled Foil-Wrapped Potatoes

As much as we all love a good grilled potato, sometimes a grill session yields more than we can eat in one sitting. Instead of letting those leftover foil-wrapped potatoes go to waste, follow these guidelines for proper storage and reheating.


First off, let your potatoes cool completely before storing. This will prevent moisture from building up in the container or bag you will be using to store them.

If you plan on eating the leftovers within the next day or two, you can simply place them into an airtight container and store them in the refrigerator. If it’s going to be longer than that, put them into freezer bags and freeze them. When freezing make certain that all air is removed from the bag by carefully pressing out excess air or sucking it out with a straw.


Now onto everyone’s favorite part – reheating! There are several ways to reheat your foil-wrapped potatoes:

1. Reheat on Grill– To get back that fresh-off-the-grill flavor set aside about 10 minutes before grilling another meal; then unwrap potatoes and warm over medium heat until heated through (5-7 minutes).

2. Microwave– Heat covered dish of unwrapped left over potatos with butter inside microwave oven until warmed through (about 3–4 minutes). Sprinkle some herbs like rosemary , parsley etc if wanted!

3.Bake/Broil/Toaster Oven – Slice open foil bundle partly exposing each cut-sized caramelized top side . Bake at high temperature around 375°F for approximatley ten-twelve mins till crispy outer layer forms .

These quick fix methods have got nothing on our secret hack though…RE-CRISP YOUR GRAVY-STAINED SIDE IN THE PANINI PRESS ! Trust us when we say there’s no greater satisfaction than biting into a hot foiled crisp potato sandwiched between melted gooey cheese thanks to our trusty little press

No matter what method you choose, keep a close eye on your potatoes to ensure they do not dry out or burn.

So next time you have leftover grilled foil-wrapped potatoes, store them properly and enjoy them all over again with one of these reheating methods. Happy snacking!

Unconventional Ways to Serve Grilled Baked Potatoes Wrapped in Foil

Grilled baked potatoes wrapped in foil are a classic side dish to any barbecue or summer gathering. But why stick to the traditional method of simply brushing them with butter and garnishing them with salt when there are so many other unconventional ways to serve this delicious treat?

One way to spice up your grilled baked potatoes is by adding different seasonings and herbs into the aluminum foil wrap. For instance, you can mix garlic powder, paprika, black pepper, and thyme for a savory flavor that will take your taste buds on an adventure.

Another option is stuffing flavorful ingredients directly into the individual potato before wrapping it in foil. You could try mixing chopped bacon bits, chives, and sour cream together before adding them as toppings inside each spud. This will not only fill the potato with tasty goodness but also make it less dry during the grilling process.

If you want something sweet instead of savory, consider rubbing brown sugar onto each potato along with some cinnamon prior to wrapping them up in tin foil. The result: caramelized sweetness that melts in your mouth!

But wait! There’s another unique twist just waiting around the corner for these humble tubers . How about topping them off with unexpected sauces such as honey mustard or hot sauce? While this may seem odd at first glance , trust us – once you take a bite out of these spicy tangy delights there won’t be any going back !

Finally let’s talk health here- if healthy eating is important to you then don’t fret even though we’re talking about delicious grilled food right now! To make things more nutritious add roasted veggies like bell peppers ,onions or beetroot directly inside topped off with feta cheese crumbles tossed over vegetable medleys .

All in all serving grilled potatoes wrapped in foil doesn’t have to be limited to old-school preparation techniques. So get creative and experiment away – because who knows what hidden genius might arise from trying new flavors! 🌟

Table with useful data:

Recipe Name Total Time Preparation Time Cook Time Serves
Baked Potatoes on the Grill in Foil 1 hour 15 minutes 45 minutes 4

Information from an expert

As a culinary specialist, I highly recommend grilling baked potatoes in foil. Not only does it make for easy clean-up, but the foil helps to seal in moisture and flavor while preventing burnt skin. Before wrapping them up, generously season with salt, pepper, and any other desired herbs/spices to infuse even more deliciousness into the potato. Place on the grill over indirect heat for about 45-60 minutes or until fork-tender. Finish off by adding toppings such as butter, cheese, sour cream, or chives for a classic comfort food that everyone will love!

Historical Fact:

Baked potatoes on the grill in foil became popular during the Great Depression as a cheap and easy meal option, especially for those living in rural areas with access to fresh potatoes.

Related Articles

Check Also
Back to top button